According to his army psychiatrist, Fort Hood shooter Ivan Lopez showed “no sign of likely violence, either to himself or to others.” While it may be possible for someone to “snap” and go on a shooting spree without warning, I have trouble believing this was the case in this incident.
Lopez had a history of depression and anxiety, yet he was still able to purchase a firearm legally (at the same store the 2009 Fort Hood shooter bought his weapon), underscoring the need for stronger background check laws for gun purchases.
“We have very strong evidence that he [Lopez] had a medical history that indicated an unstable psychiatric or psychological condition,” Lt. Gen. Mark Milley, head of the Army’s III Corps at Fort Hood, said of Lopez. “There was no indication that he was targeting specific people.”
3 people are dead 16 more are wounded. The questions we as a nation now face are:
1) Could this tragedy have been prevented? (were there warning signs?)
2) How can we prevent similar tragedies from happening in the future?
These two questions are obviously related. If there were warning signs, then recognizing these signs can help prevent similar tragedies from happening.
The warning signs, beyond Lopez’s mental health record, came in the form of Facebook posts:
1) On March 1, the same day he purchased the .45-caliber semiautomatic pistol he used in the attack, Specialist Lopez wrote an especially angry and vaguely threatening post. “My spiritual peace has all gone away, I am full of hate, I believe now the devil is taking me. I was robbed last night and I’m sure it was two flacos. Green light and thumbs down. It’s just that easy …”
2) In a Facebook post, Specialist Lopez said of the Newtown massacre: “For me, the direct responsibility for this situation is with the psychiatrist, who didn’t uncover Adam’s level of dangerousness so that he could be restricted.”
Read posthumously, these posts depict someone who was unable to grasp the concept of personal accountability. On the other hand, hindsight is always 20-20; these posts were separated by over a year, during which time Lopez probably made many posts which are irrelevant to his mental state.
Taken separately, each of these pieces of “evidence”; a questionable mental health history, delusional Facebook posts, and a gun purchase; could not be considered a red flag–it would be impossible to police all social media platforms. But taken together, they form the profile of an individual who is very likely a risk to himself and others.
What someone posts on social media can get them fired or (if a public figure) publicly ridiculed–American’s clearly take social media postings seriously. What can we do when someone writes about hurting themselves or others on social media? At what point does protecting a persons right to privacy prohibit the ability to protect another persons right to life? As a social scientist, I am constantly looking for “information”; is it possible that we are overlooking a valuable source of information in social media posts?
I already alluded to the need for stronger background checks for gun purchases, another preventative measure is greater access to mental healthcare, which I believe should be a human right (it is currently viewed as a luxury for the wealthy). Specialist Lopez was covered as an Army employee; what about people out there without mental health coverage? Obamacare has gone a long way in rewriting insurance guidelines to cover mental healthcare, and subsidizes plans for those who cannot afford insurance on their own, but what about people who are still not covered? Given the various ramifications of untreated mental illness (crime, poverty, etc.), is it time to consider investing more tax dollars into walk-in mental health clinics?
These issues, privacy and security, lend themselves to heated debates. I leave my readers with these loaded questions to ponder.
April 7, 2014 at 6:59 pm
The things to remember about this man was first, he was in Iraq or Afghanistan, both insane wars that have seriously affected the sanity of soldiers. Second, he was put on psychotropic drugs, well-known as causing intense behavior. Evidently he was denied a request to attend his mother’s funeral until the military relented, surely enough to push the sanest man over the edge. End illegal wars where men are either killing innocent civilians or witnessing others doing so, and the men and women won’t be driven to madness.
April 9, 2014 at 8:58 pm
Ben, Thought you’d find the following post very insightful…
April 10, 2014 at 1:27 pm
You would think with all the progressive people out there, we could actually fill watchdog organizations with people committed to social justice.
Also, you would hope that different agencies could work towards their common goal, as opposed to fighting for “relevance” based on a the number of cases they bring.
I then into these problems when applying for jobs. Nobody wants someone with who is willing to rock the boat, they fear that “destructive progress”. They want insiders, people who know the industry, and corruption persists.
Pingback: Transparency Report: Preventing Tragedy Revisited | Normative Narratives
Pingback: RIP NYPD Officers Rafael Ramos and Wenjian Liu | Normative Narratives